Are you in a hurry?
Here is a quick list of Hotels in Shelter Island, selected based on their rating
| Name of hotel | Accommodation Rating | Price, $ | |
| The Pridwin Hotel |
9.0 / 10 (78 Reviews) |
From 334$ | |
| Ram'S Head Inn |
7.9 / 10 (47 Reviews) |
From 407$ | |
| Seven Resort Style Inn Near Beach |
9.9 / 10 (87 Reviews) |
From 232$ | |
| Sunset Beach |
8.2 / 10 (8 Reviews) |
From 596$ |
View all photos
Located approximately 10 minutes by car from Greenport, the 4-star Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island offers Wi-Fi in public areas and a car park. Boasting a seasonal outdoor pool, this Shelter Island hotel is nestled within 7 km of natural attractions like Lavender By the Bay Farm.
The accommodation is about 90 km from Long Island MacArthur airport and a 10-minute ride from such cultural venues as Railroad Museum of Long Island. Guests will also get to the Pridwin Shelter Island a 10-minute drive from Sylvester Manor Educational Farm. A private beach is around a 5-minute walk from this Shelter Island property, while Fireboat Firefighter Museum is situated a 10-minute ride away. The nearby family attractions include Greenport Antique Carousel at a distance of 3.9 km from The Pridwin Hotel.
View all photos
Situated 15 minutes' drive from Lavender By the Bay Farm, the 3-star Rams Head Inn Shelter Island features Wi-Fi in the rooms and a car park on site. This Shelter Island inn is located in a beach area, about a 15-minute ride from Nova Constellatio Gallery, which is an interesting cultural attraction.
The accommodation is situated nearly 5 minutes' walk from an own beach. Montauk is 30 km from the hotel, while Railroad Museum of Long Island is a 15-minute ride away. Nature lovers will appreciate the proximity to Lower Beach, which is approximately a 5-minute walk away. Sylvester Manor Educational Farm is 3.4 km from Rams Head Inn.
View all photos
Offering access to Nova Constellatio Gallery, which is approximately 10 minutes away by car, the 4-star Seven - A Boutique B&B On Shelter Island features a sun terrace, a golf course, and a garden. Featuring a heated swimming pool, this Shelter Island bed & breakfast is a 15-minute ride from natural sights like Lavender By the Bay Farm.
The traditional property is about 85 km from Long Island MacArthur airport and 10 minutes' drive such cultural venues as Railroad Museum of Long Island. Stamford is 99 km from the Seven - A Boutique B&B On, while the locally run aquaculture Southold Bay Oysters Farm is nearly 10 minutes away by car. Nature lovers will appreciate the proximity to Crescent Beach, which is about 25 minutes' walk away. Seven - A Boutique B&B On Shelter Island lies at a distance of 3.3 km from East End Seaport Museum and Marine Foundation.
View all photos
Sunset Beach
From 596$
Situated a 10-minute ride from the locally run aquaculture Southold Bay Oysters Farm, the 4-star Sunset Beach Shelter Island hotel offers proximity to various city highlights. This Shelter Island hotel includes 20 rooms.
The centre of Shelter Island can be reached within a 5-minute walk, and natural attractions like Mashomack Preserve are 4.5 km away. At the hotel you'll be around 25 minutes' walk from Crescent Beach. This Shelter Island property is situated 10 minutes' drive Fireboat Firefighter Museum. Long Island MacArthur is the nearest airport, 85 km from Sunset Beach hotel.
Hotels in Shelter Island
| Top Service Hotel 🛁 | The Pridwin Hotel |
| Top Hotel for couples 💑 | Ram'S Head Inn |
| Best mid-range Hotel 🌴 | Seven Resort Style Inn Near Beach |